Speaking About War

by Berry Friesen

Berry f

The April 6 US attack on Syria brings to the surface a hardy perennial:  hand-wringing over what Jesus-followers should say about such military attacks.

The hand-wringing occurs because (a) Jesus taught us to love our enemies, a stance incompatible with deliberately killing them; and (b) Jesus taught us to love our neighbors, which surely includes protecting the innocent from terror and aggression.  Doing both at once is a steep challenge.

Those loyal to the power of the state are prone to ignore the first teaching and emphasize the second.  Thus, with regard to Syria, the mainstream media present us with innocent and defenseless women and children being victimized by President Bashar al-Assad, a brutal and violent oppressor who uses poison gas to kill and intimidate.  The presentation is designed to justify the use of violence to protect the innocent.

Jesus-followers can do better than that.

For example, on April 7, Mennonite Central Committee (MCC)—the international NGO that represents US Mennonites, Amish and Brethren in Christ congregations—issued a public call urging its supporters to oppose US military action against Syria.  After noting the civilian deaths on April 4 from “a chemical weapons attack” and the US airstrikes on Syria April 6—“an act of war without debate or approval by the US Congress or UN Security Council”—MCC conveyed the opposition of its Syrian partners to

“the use of violence from all sides in the conflict, including chemical weapons, airstrikes and the bombardment of villages – events that have all taken place this week. Rather than fueling the flames of war, they urge support instead for a robust process of dialogue and diplomacy to address the root causes of the conflict.”

Notice how the short MCC statement implicitly honors both of Jesus’ teachings.  Notice also how it includes relevant facts, including a couple that reflect poorly on the US.

Yet the statement seems a bit perfunctory for a war that has entered its seventh year. Its call for an end to the violence and a negotiated settlement is rather conventional; I can’t imagine a US official or military officer being offended by such a call, nor any editor of a mainstream newspaper.

Evil is running amok in Syria; nearly 500,000 have been killed, six million people have become refugees, another six million have been internally displaced.  Why does this carnage continue?  People of faith must have something to say about this. How do we do this?

First, we must clarify what’s going on in Syria.

  • President Assad is defending his country against outside invaders led by al-Qaeda and ISIS. These terrorist groups have been supported in Syria by money, arms, training and intelligence from the US and its allies.  Saudi Arabia and Qatar have been especially important sources of support for these groups; the US provides technical expertise and also plays a coordinating role.
  • In Idlib province where the April 6th chemical incident occurred, al-Qaeda is in control. Most of the on-the-ground information reported in the Western media about the deaths on April 6 has been provided by individuals and groups working with al-Qaeda.
  • During the long Syria war, investigative teams of the United Nations have documented chemical weapons use by al-Qaeda, by ISIS and by the Syrian government. Responsibility for the largest such attack—the August, 2013 attack in Ghouta—remains unclear.
  • Russia is militarily present in Syria at the invitation of the Syrian government; thus, its presence conforms to international law. The US has no legal basis for military involvement in Syria; its presence in Syria is a violation of international law.

Second, we must summon the courage to identify parties to the Syrian war that apparently want this horror to continue.  I refer to “courage” here because accurately describing the agony of Syria will be viewed by some as a breach of loyalty to our tribe.  This breach can bring consequences:  loss of reputation, marginalization, even exclusion.

Tulsi Gabbard, the Democrat congresswoman and former US Army officer from Hawaii, is a vivid example.  For going to Syria late last year and visiting President Assad, expressing skepticism about al-Qaeda-sourced reports that are published by Western media, and calling for an independent investigation of the April 6th chemical event, Gabbard has been denounced by leading members of her party.  She is likely to face a challenge in the next Democratic primary.  Her constituents may decide to throw her out of office.

But Gabbard has refused to back down.  She even has introduced legislation (H.R. 608) prohibiting US support for al-Qaeda and ISIS in Syria.  Think about it:  Gabbard says it is necessary to make it illegal for the US government to do what you and I would be thrown in jail for doing:  supporting the evil of terrorism.

Raised by a Christian father, Gabbard now practices the Hindu faith.  Yet she provides an example of what we Jesus-followers must find the courage to do as we speak in public settings about war:  grapple with the evil that explains the apparent intractability of war.

Yes, this means casting blame.  And of course, the standard response is that casting blame will get us nowhere.

Actually, however, that’s not true.  Blame has already been cast a million times through Western media reports stigmatizing President Assad and his administration’s attempts to defend their country against foreign mercenaries and terrorists. This pattern of media blame-casting is a powerful force that has indeed got us somewhere:  six-plus years of war, justified by a false moral imperative to remove President Assad from office.

So yes, we must do more than oppose war and the re-arming of the combatants.  We must do more than call for a negotiated settlement.  We also must identify the presence of evil pushing war ever onward.  And we must oppose this evil, even if it gets us in trouble with our tribe.

———————————————————————————

Berry Friesen lives in Lancaster, PA and is part of the East Chestnut Street Mennonite congregation in that city.  A version of this essay was previously published at his blog,  www.bible-and-empire.net

 

 

 

 

 

Advertisements

4 responses to “Speaking About War

  1. When one makes assertions intended to “clarify what’s going on in Syria,” that are on their face contrary not only to stated policy but also obvious military acts of aggression toward Al Qaeda and ISIS by the USA, it behooves one to provide supportive evidence. Further, you might want to elaborate on the complex history of the civil war in Syria rather than making patently oversimplified statements. You say: “President Assad is defending his country against outside invaders led by al-Qaeda and ISIS. These terrorist groups have been supported in Syria by money, arms, training and intelligence from the US and its allies. Saudi Arabia and Qatar have been especially important sources of support for these groups; the US provides technical expertise and also plays a coordinating role.” So you are actually asserting that the USA is coordinating Al Qaeda and ISIS forces? Really?

    • I accept your point, RW, though it does not cause me to withdraw mine. I write frequently about Syria at http://www.bbile-and-empire.net. You can read a thumbnail history of the war in Syria at “The ‘Fall’ of Alleppo?” there. Here is the URL: http://www.bible-and-empire.net/2016/12/the-fall-of-aleppo.html

      Thank you for keying on the critical factor: the relationship between the US-led alliance dedicated to removing Syran President Assad from power and the ground troops (ISIS and al-Qaeda) attacking the Syrian army, Syrian infrastructure and Syrian civil society. We hear little about this relationship in the Western media, and it is a key factor.

      Obviously, I am convinced they work together hand-in-glove and that the US–as leader of the alliance assembled to bring about regime change in Syria–provides overall coordination and leadership. Within the parameters of this publication, I can write nothing that will convince you of this assertion, but perhaps I can convince you that the question deserves your careful attention.

      There is indeed indiginous opposition to Assad’s government in Syria today, as there was in 2011 when the warfare began. But from the start, covert forces used that popular uprising as a pretense to implement a very sinister agenda: dismantling yet another secular Middle East government (Iraq and Libya being the first two).

      It is a crime, what the US and its allies have done to Syria. Please acquaint yourself with this crime, and then add your voice to those calling for it to end.

    • Thank you for your note, Evie asnd Wally. And for your website. I will share your recent post on “Islamic psalms” with my Muslim son-in-law.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s